Jessica Dodge on dreams, magic & the stories we carry within.

The author of six books, including her bestselling The Forgotten Witch Trilogy, Jessica Dodge never thought she would one day be a writer, And yet, she discovered a new calling in an unexpected chapter of her life. She draws on folklore, history, and the natural beauty of her home in Vermont to create enchanting stories filled with magic, myth, and mystery.


“Our struggles are what build us up to becoming the person that can hold our dreams”


We talk about Jessica’s surprising connection to the Salem Witch Trials, the magic of ordinary things, and her love of antiques, woodland flowers, and forest mushrooms. Her atmospheric writing and intricate plots reveal a storyteller who doesn’t just listen to the whispered stories left behind, but creates them.

Welcome and Road to Publication

Hello, everyone. Welcome to another episode of Whispers at the Garden Gate. I have Jessica Dodge today. She is a very good friend, as it happens, and I’m so glad to have her on the show. Jess, welcome!

Thank you so much. I’m so excited to be on here today.

Tell us about yourself and your relationship to literature growing up. How did you decide to become an author?

Hello, everybody. My name is Jessica Dodge. I am a magical realism author who also writes historical fantasy. I am about five years into being an author at this point, and I am on my sixth book. So anybody who is into magic and witches, you’re my readers.

I’m going to be completely honest and say that I hated reading when I was younger. Absolutely hated it. I was bad at it, and I was criticized ridiculously badly in school. I grew up in the ’80s, and so back then they kind of thought that letting kids pick on you or belittle you in class would help you learn. And so I had a severe terror of reading aloud at school because I had been picked on so badly. It followed me all the way through into high school. I used to have to have my parents go in and talk to the principals to tell them not to have me read aloud in class because it gave me such bad panic attacks that I would actually get physically sick. So I did not enjoy reading. It wasn’t until I think I was a senior in high school that I started to actually read for enjoyment. It was after reading The Great Gatsby. I think in 11th grade, I read The Great Gatsby, and I actually really liked it. It was one of those books that I identified with as a teenager, wanting to be part of the cool kids’ crowd and that kind of thing.

I really wanted to go to school for film. I started reading the books that inspired some of my favorite movies that were happening at the time. So that was my first real jaunt into becoming a reader, when I was pretty much a senior in high school. Then I decided I was going to go to school for film, and I did that. I learned how to write scripts, and that was my first real writing experience. I always knew that I was a storyteller. I had done small movies in school. I had playmations in school. I was a visual artist. I’ve tried to get into a couple of different big art schools, like RISD and stuff, which obviously didn’t happen, and I’m glad because I ended up going to film school instead. But it was that whole background that led me to becoming the storyteller that I am today. And I think that’s why a lot of people like my books, because I write in a very theatrical way. I really immerse my readers in my stories as if they’re watching a movie. My details are really, you know, the atmospheric aspect is what a lot of people call my writing.

You took the words out of my mouth. I was going to say your work is very atmospheric. I hate to ask how you get inspiration because, you know, none of us know. It just hits you every once in a while. But where do you get inspiration from? You live in Vermont now, New England, hence you’re here in the New England season, Voices of New England. But what does nature mean to you when it comes to writing?

You know, I absolutely love where I live. I live in a very magical setting. I feel like I live in a little storybook area. We live down a one-lane road that only has a couple of houses on it, and we’re surrounded by hundreds of acres of forest all around us.

So there is just so much inspiration for the stories that I have. One of my favorite things to do is, there are all these trails that are used for snowmobiling. And so they’re great walking trails in all the other times of the year. We go on them; they’re all through the woods around where we live. I walk them, and I come across old foundations and old stone walls. And those kinds of things are very inspiring for the atmosphere I write about.

I’m actually currently writing a book that has to do with a stone wall. And I get the inspiration not from the stone wall that I saw around where I was, but a good friend of mine was in England and had taken a picture of a stone wall on his walk. And it was this beautiful sunset against this stone wall. It just sparked the idea for the book. It’s so weird because sometimes, because I’m a visual person, it’s the visual stuff that really gets me, or things that I’ve read. I read a lot of articles.

My book Misplaced Magic actually came from an article I read about a woman in England who had been digging in her flower garden and found a medallion that was like 200 years old. And so that’s what sparked the whole idea. It was just that article, just this old lady finding this medallion. It’s funny, like you said, it’s so hard to say what inspires you because there are so many different things that inspire you. Something will inspire the idea for a book, but then there are all the little things that inspire the scenes for the book too. You know what I mean? So, yeah.

The Stories Behind the Witch Trials & Jessica’s Ancestral Connection to Salem

What drew you to witches and especially to Scottish folklore?

So I have lineage back to the Salem Witch Trials. One of the women who was accused and killed there was actually one of my mother’s ancestors. And I come to find out, when my husband, who is very big into genealogy, was going back through his family genealogy, that his great-great-great-grandfather was the one who accused my relative. How crazy is that, right?

Oh my! How is this not the book yet?

I know, I know, I know. I’ve had so many people say that. It’s so funny because I said we’re breaking ancestral bonds there. But anyways, when I started writing my trilogy, I started with The Forgotten Witch. And it was never like I never set out to actually write a trilogy because each one of the books is really its own separate story. There are interlocking characters from each of the stories in each of the books, but it’s not a trilogy in the way that we think of trilogies. I like to call it a chronicle.

When I was researching the witch trials in Scotland, I had, of course, because when growing up in New England, we learned all about the Salem Witch Trials. That was a huge part of our curriculum in school. I had no idea that it had actually started over in Scotland. And this was something that really surprised me because they could have told us this back in high school, and I just don’t remember. It just blew me away that it had all started over there quite a bit longer than it was over here. So it started in Scotland back in the 1590s, when King James was trying to get his bride, whom he had married by proxy over in Denmark, over to Scotland.

She was supposed to get on a boat and be shipped over to him. Every time she got on this boat to be shipped to him, there was a storm, and she wasn’t able to come. So finally, she had gotten on the ship again and had gotten stranded in Norway because of a storm. And he immediately went to the thought that this was witches keeping him from his bride. So that’s where the witch hysteria actually started. There were whispers that there were women who were trying to keep this woman, the Queen of Denmark, from coming over to Scotland to marry him, to be his wife. So that rolled into this big, huge witch hysteria that lasted right up into the main part in the 1640s, and that was when it got really bad.

They executed, over 2,500 people in Scotland during the witch trials. And if you think about it, it’s funny that we don’t hear about that as much because there were only 36 people who were pretty much murdered for being witches over here in the US during colonial times. I just think that’s a really interesting thing when it comes to where you’re from and what history you hear, you know? Because we’re hearing all about, as children growing up in New England, it’s all about the Salem Witch Trials and how horrible it was. And that hysteria definitely had spread from Scotland to the Americas at the time. But the Salem Witch Trials didn’t take place until the late 1600s. That was like 1692.

There was a long period of time there, from the late 1500s until the late 1600s, when there was this huge amount of accusation and murder going on in Scotland over witches. And it kind of bled over into the Salem Witch Trials. So I just thought that was an interesting piece that I learned about when I was doing my research.

Yes, so true. And even beyond Scotland, there were a lot of other countries that had witch trials across Europe. Yeah, and it was devastating in the 1500s and 1600s too. But how do you approach your research since the settings are in Scotland and Wales for your books? And how do you balance the documented history and folklore, because you use so much myth and folklore, with the fictional world-building?

The most beautiful thing about being a fiction writer is you can bend things a little bit. If you could see around me right now, I have hundreds of research books. I’m a huge book nerd with research books. I actually have more research books than I have regular books because I love researching. When I was writing that trilogy, especially when I got into Misplaced Magic, that was a lot of King Arthur lore. And I wasn’t really into any King Arthur lore. I hadn’t been a big reader of that as a young person or an adult. And so I learned a lot about that by obviously reading the King Arthur stories.

Then I also, during that period for that book, had to research a lot about Wales and the different historical folklore that went around with that, and then try to weave them all together, right? Because that’s the Lady of the Lake story. And so that’s one of the most fun parts, I think, about being an author, being able to take all these little bits of history and folklore and your own imagination and weave them into a tale that’s believable, right? Even if it’s not believable, it’s believable.

I saw this review of my book the other day that I thought was one of the biggest compliments. They were like, “This author has taken an unbelievable situation and made it completely believable.” I’m like, that is the best compliment. So I think that for me, research is different in a lot of ways too, because for somebody who’s writing about magic, and I’m not somebody who practices magic, I’ve got to learn all about this, right? In doing that, it’s like getting a book, learning about it, actually buying the herbs, looking at what they look like, smelling what they smell like. Because that’s what really immerses a reader in the story, giving them those senses, right? So if you can tell them, you know, she’s unwrapping the rosemary bundle and the sharp scent of the rosemary, those kinds of details are what bring the reader into the scene. So in order to write a scene that has those details, you have to know what those details are and experience them for yourself.

However, when I was writing my books, it was during COVID. So I was not able to actually go to Wales. I have been trying to go to places now that I’m writing full-time, to experience what these places are like with my feet on the ground. But I couldn’t do that at that time because it was during COVID. So I went on Google Maps and I walked the streets of the town, like all the streets. I just, you know, Google-mapped it like I was wandering through the streets of Beddgelert. And it was amazing because it really helped me be able to describe the village in the best way possible because I could actually see it, you know, which is an amazing tool. If any of the readers or writers are listening right now, it’s a really great tool for a place you haven’t been to that you really need to have good descriptions of.

The Forgotten Witch and When a Story Finds it’s Creator

Tell us about your debut, The Forgotten WItch, and how did the story come to you?

So before I was a writer, I was an artist. I had gone to film school. I ended up not doing anything with my degree because I had children, and it’s not conducive to 14-hour days of filming. I became a stay-at-home mom, and I started my own business where I was making toys. I had a toy company. It was lots of hours of painting because I did heirloom dolls for dollhouses, which were all hand-painted, and everything was done from scratch. I had a bunch of people working for me, and I’d spend hours painting and listening to audiobooks.

I was going through audiobooks so quickly because I was spending 12 hours painting, and I had fallen in love with Paula Brackston’s books. She’s my favorite author. I listened to all of them, and I was so sad I didn’t have any more Paula Brackston books to listen to. So I thought, I would love to write a book like that someday.

This was during 2020, during the rush of people being stuck in their homes, and my business, unlike a lot of people’s businesses, actually boomed during that time. It became so big that I could not run it even with a bunch of people working with me. I was literally working, like I said, 12-hour days just to keep up with demand. And I ended up having a mini-stroke. It was a small one and I recovered quickly. There was no lasting damage or anything, but it was definitely my wake-up call that having my arms propped up and painting for 12 hours a day was causing problems with my neck.

So I pretty much one day was just like, “God, please help me figure out some other way to do this because I can’t do this anymore.” And then I swear, the next day I had this idea for a book. For me, if you were to tell me six years ago, “Hey, you’re going to write a book and you’re going to become an author,” I would have laughed because I never thought of myself as somebody who was literary in any way. I decided, I’m going to write this book. And so I started. I sat down and started typing. I didn’t even write a plot down. I’m a pantser, so I didn’t write a plot down. I didn’t do anything. I just started typing on my computer.

And every day I was more and more immersed in this world, and I had more ideas. Then I was buying more research books, and I was really getting into it. I’d go up to my Airstream, which is where I write, and I would spend hours up there in the evening writing this book. And it was so funny because it just kind of flowed out of me. I didn’t even know I had it in me to do this, you know? And it just flowed out of me.

I think back on that now, and it’s almost like I was channeling this book. I think that I download this stuff and just write it because of the way I write. I don’t plot it. I don’t do anything. I have very complex plots in my books too. And if you look at my notebooks, my notebooks are pretty much just names, dates, ideas for spells. There isn’t a lot of “This is what’s going to happen next.” No timelines. Nothing like that. There are character descriptions, ideas, lots of drawings and art in my notebooks, because that’s what inspires me. So it’s just funny to look back now. I cannot believe that I sat down and wrote that book in six months. I’d never written anything. I’d never published short stories. I’d never done anything of this sort. And it just came out of me. It was almost otherworldly.

Wow. And for so many who say, “I’ve never really thought about being an author,” or “I wasn’t really a big reader,” there are all these things that people tell themselves, like, “Who’s going to want to read something I write?” Right? But you’re such a testament to the fact that when you put your mind to something… because you didn’t have to sit every day and write it, but you did. And you made it happen. And I love that you’re a visual person, you love art, and this is what keeps you going. But it’s the story, ultimately, that has a life on its own and, I guess, spoke to you.

Yes, for sure. And, you know, I have had so many people in the last four years tell me that they picked up a pen and paper and started writing their book because I inspired them. I never hid my story from anyone when people ask. I never would have thought I would have written a book. That’s not who I am. I always thought I was bad at this kind of stuff. But it’s never too late to do anything either. I didn’t publish my book until I was almost 40, and now I have the career I never knew I wanted. So it’s funny how things lead you in different directions. And as long as you can follow the signs and the synchronicities, and you pay attention, you’ll get there.

How do you approach your writing schedule and your research? Do you do the research before you start writing? Do you write every day once you have the idea?

Normally, I try to write at least two hours a day. That’s usually what my schedule is. However, we have a foreign exchange student living with us this year. And so my daughter, who I normally homeschool, is in school with her. So my schedule’s been a little thrown off. But yes, I try to sit down. Usually at night, I write two hours, which equals about a chapter a day. And depending on how much research I need, I don’t do all my research prior to writing. I do research as I go because I’m a pantser. I don’t know exactly where the story is going to go. So if all of a sudden it leads me to a cathedral in, you know, Paris, I’m going to have to go and research that before I write it.

The Magic Hidden in Everyday Objects

All right. So you say, and I’m quoting here, I had to write it down so I don’t misquote you: “Magic is all around us sometimes. It just takes a good book to open our eyes to it.” And in your work, you use a lot of secrets, objects, bookshops, books, which I love. What do you think makes all these old bookshops and cottages and secrets so magical?

Gosh, that’s a good question. I think that anything that’s old is steeped in some sort of magic. And I say that because I think that magic… and I believe in magic. I believe there is so much around us that we take it for granted. When you’re thinking about I should do this, or I’m upset about that, and feel like can’t make it through, and then you look over at your clock and it says 1:11. There are these little hints around us all the time that show us that there’s something bigger than us out there.

One of my favorite things to do is treasure hunting in antique stores and thrift shops and stuff like that because a lot of times ideas for books come from things I find there. I found this amazing old mirror, and it’s part of a new book. Behind me, I have a huge stack of postcards I found at a yard sale. And it’s all these amazing postcards from all over the world back in the 1940s.

I think that the magic we feel in these things is actually people’s imprinted energy. The people who came before us, who have looked at these books, who have been in the shop, who have touched these items, they’re putting that energy that they have into them. Like,this brand-new beautiful mirror that somebody bought for somebody in the 1920s. It probably was an amazing gift that someone loved for generations, and it was passed down. Then it ends up in some old thrift shop, sitting there for a dollar, and I pick it up, and I’m just like, my Gosh this is amazing. You can feel that imprinted energy. And I think that’s the magic these things hold.

Yes, I was just going to say that. That entire age, at the beginning of that century is just filled with stories about, extravagant spendings and the highlife that sometimes leads to dark places.

Yes! I think that what happens after a lengthy, devastating war the survivors are at a loss. They’ve lost a lot in various ways, and they’re sort of desperate to celebrate life, to feel alive, to somehow lighten and mitigate all that darkness. So they throw themselves into wild abandon with excess. I mean, you saw it after the French Revolution too.

A Message for Future Generations

If you could write something for future generations to find and leave in a book, what would the note say and what would the book be?

Such a great question.

Okay, so the book would be The Way of the Peaceful Warrior by Dan Millman. And that is because that book came to me at the very perfect moment in my life. I think that book is one of these magic books that comes to people when they need it. I actually had the honor of meeting Dan. He came to a writing retreat that I put on a couple of years ago, and he was a phenomenal person. But I would definitely leave it in that book.

And I think I would say: When life is putting you through the wringer and you feel like everything is falling apart and your world is crumbling, it’s just your higher self building you up to the point where you can take on your dreams and succeed with them.

Because I think a lot of times our struggles are what build us up to becoming the person who can hold those dreams.

I love that. And what would you like for your readers to take away from your books?

I think the most important part of my books is that people have the sense that nothing is impossible, that everything in this world is possible if you have your eyes open and you’re able to see it.

Books That Inspire: Jessica’s Reading Recommendations

Do you have any book recommendations. For people who love your stories, who would you recommend?

I absolutely love Paula Brackston. Her book, The Silver Witch, is one of my all-time favorite books.

I also love Barbara Davis, and her book, The Echo of Old Books, is one of my favorites. It’s such a good book. Such a good book.

I love Natalie Banks’ work, and she’s actually got a new thriller that’s coming out. This is a little bit different genre, but if you like those kinds of books, she’s got great ones.

I think that everybody should read Romeo and Juliet, because I think that is probably the best love story ever written in a cinematic way. I just feel like it’s inspired so many other books and movies and art. I think that’s definitely something that everybody should read. Most people, I think, do because you have to do it in school. But I think it’s definitely one that you should pick up as an adult and read again too.

I really loved The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue. That was one of my favorite books I read this past year because I had taken a little bit of a reading hiatus. I was working so much that I didn’t have much time to read, which is a problem when you’re an author. I listen to a lot of audiobooks still because if I’m driving the kids to school in the car or something like that, I have time. But that was by far one of my favorite reads of the year. And I know it’s an older book; it came out a few years ago, but it was definitely one of my favorites this year.

Bookshops that Hold a Special Place

Do you have any favorite bookshops you could recommend?

You know, being in Vermont and being where I live, there are very few in the area.

So my favorite bookshop, my absolute favorite bookshop, which does not exist anymore, was Dartmouth Books down in Hanover, New Hampshire, where Dartmouth College is. And I spent many, many days in that bookstore when I was younger. Sadly, it dissolved with many of the bookshops during COVID. But there are some smaller bookshops. There’s Starcat Books in my town, which is a small little shop that’s super cute. She’s got a lot of used books in there and newer books, which is fun. Then there’s another smaller bookshop in our town too. Our town is very small, and we have two little bookshops.

The other one is run by an older woman who is in her eighties, and she actually does bookbinding and the oiling on the cover pages, like the old-fashioned way. She still does it in the basement of that shop. So I think that’s really cool. It’s part of a thrift store, so it’s like a thrift store and a bookstore. She’s a very avid collector of inkwells, and so I’ve spent many, many hundreds of dollars on inkwells here because they’re so amazing.

But yeah, those are probably my two favorites.

A Garden of Wildflowers and Woodland Wonders

You write about magic, and I have to ask about gardens. What are your favorite gardens?

So, because I live in the woods, I am definitely drawn to my wildflowers. I love wildflowers. My favorite, though, is, and I don’t know if this is the actual name of the flower. I think it might be. It’s called a starflower. They’re very small. They grow on the sides of the road up here, and they open. They’re white, and when they open, they’re exactly the shape of a star. They are the most beautiful, magical-looking flowers you’ve ever seen. I’m probably wrong with the name of them, but they’re my favorites.

And I also love any of the wildflowers. I don’t even know half their names, but we had a massive amount of wildflowers everywhere in Vermont this summer in particular. It was a great year for them. I think it’s because we had a lot of snow, so the ground was very nourished. And we had a really great fall this year too. The foliage was just absolutely unreal.

I love the woods. I grew up in the mountains, so I can totally relate. For me, just seeing the wildflowers in the spring and the summer too, it’s the next level of joy. It’s almost magic, like you said.

It is. It is. It’s. Like when you’re looking out in a field and there are purples and yellows and these amazing varieties of colors just popping up. And there’s something so magical about that. There really is.

It’s a dose of happy, I call it.

Mushrooms! I love mushrooms too. If you could see my phone, if you could see the pictures in my phone, I probably have more pictures of mushrooms than I do my kids, right? Because I love going in, like I call it my mushroom-foraging time, when I’m walking the trails. This time of year, there are so many mushrooms, from the beginning of fall to right about now. Now they’re all dead because we’ve gotten frosts.

But there are some magical mushrooms around here. I took a walk, I think a month and a half ago, on this trail I go to that has this lake in the middle of the woods at the end of it. On the trail, I came across pink mushrooms, which I’d never seen before, and these yellow mushrooms that look like Mario. I mean, I had, I think, fifteen different mushrooms by the time I got back on my phone. I was showing my husband, and he was like, “Mm-hmm, okay. You and your mushrooms again.” I really do enjoy finding mushrooms because they’re so fun to photograph.

Yes. I can imagine a pink or yellow mushroom would be. We used to forage mushrooms when I was growing up, but to eat. This sounds really fun.

It’s so cool.

What’s Next For Jessica Dodge

What’s next for you? Is there any news we can expect? What are you working on right now, as much as you can share?

Yeah, so right now I’ve got two books.

I have one book that’s out for submission, which we’re hoping to hear back from soon. It’s a little bit off my genre. It’s actually a cozy horror. I don’t want to say it’s off my genre, though, because it’s actually a haunted house book that takes place in England. So it’s definitely… It’s got my vibe. It’s definitely Jessica Dodge vibes. It’s just a little bit spookier, but not super scary and not gory. It’s just a little darker than what I normally write. I had written it last year during this time in a month and a half. I think it was like two and a half months, but it just poured out of me. I was writing like six hours a day then because I just couldn’t get this book out of my mind.

So I’m really excited about that.

The book that I’m finishing right now, which I am over the moon about, is called The Cursed Painting of Gabrielle Moretti.

This one actually takes place in Italy. So this is a little bit different than my normal books because we’re traveling a little bit further away from Scotland. It does have parts in England, though. They travel from America to England and then from England to Italy. So it still has a little bit of that. Another one of my dual timelines, dual POVs. We have a male character and a female character who have split chapters, like The Messengers of Magic.

It’s about a painter who has accidentally cursed his painting of him and his beloved, and how that transfers through time. Our two main characters are a priest and a journalist. So it’s a fun one. I’m really liking it.

And this one is particularly very cool because I am working with a classical painter who is painting the scenes from the book. She’s actually painting scenes from the book and painting the paintings that are in the book. When this whole thing comes together, we’re planning on doing an exhibition with the release of the book so that you can view the images and the paintings that she’s created and the pages of the book that go with it. Then we have a composer who’s working on doing a whole entire sonata that goes through the full scenes of the love story in the book.

So it’s going to be an all-immersive experience. If you go on my page, you can find Jenny Bravo. She’s an amazing artist, and we’re working together. You’ll be seeing posts where she’s sharing what she’s doing as we’re working through this together. So it’s a pretty amazing project.

What a fascinating, fascinating project. I can’t wait for everything to unfold. It sounds like such a spectacular story and everything you had envisioned. That’s lovely, lovely.

I feel like it’s going to be a different… it’s going to be an all-immersive experience for a book. It’s going to be totally different.

So it’s going to be all the senses. And this is what I’m talking about, coming from my background in art. I can’t not have that kind of stuff in my writing too.

Yes, and I think that’s what makes you so unique and so special, and this is why people love your work. That’s amazing. So happy for you.

A Final Word

Do you have any parting words for the audience?

I just hope that you guys pick up a book, and it doesn’t even have to be mine. Just pick up a book today and enjoy floating away to another reality.

Thank you so much, Jessica, for being on the show, for your time and generosity, and wishing you all the best.

Thank you so much for having me.

Similar Posts